When Is a Standard Footing Design Not Enough?
A standard footing design is not enough when the site, building or proposed details fall outside the design's prescribed conditions. AS 2870-2011 also provides for design using engineering principles. Where the prescribed route does not apply, design the actual system under the applicable Section 4 provisions rather than copying a detail from a superficially similar house.
Check the permitted design scope, not only the site class
Clause 3.1.1 excludes Class E and Class P sites as well as specified building lengths and forms, permanent slab joints, some suspended upper concrete floors and particular support arrangements. The conditions include qualifications for some cases: for example the exclusion for a suspended concrete first floor in two-storey construction refers to an exception under clause 3.9. The rule for columns and fireplaces also depends on the stated conditions. Check the whole provision rather than treating a similar floor plan or class as sufficient.
Houses of the same floor area can have different footing demands. A long narrow slab has different geometry from a compact one, and masonry can introduce different loads and movement constraints from framed construction. AS 2870-2011 clause 3.1.1 also excludes concrete strengths of 32 MPa and greater from the standard designs. Specifying stronger concrete does not bring an otherwise excluded design back within scope.
Changes to a prescribed detail can change the structure
Clause 3.4.1 requires engineering design for modifications to the prescribed waffle-raft details. Ribs and edge beams are arranged for continuity and transfer loads to the foundation in a particular way. Moving a wall or opening a service route can change where those loads reach a rib or whether the beam remains continuous. A local detail needs to be assessed with the system it alters.
Not every site difference needs the same response. Some specific conditions, such as certain local rock outcrops, have prescribed details under AS 2870-2011. If the condition or proposed alteration falls outside those limits, establish how the design will maintain bearing and stiffness. Thickening concrete or adding a pier can introduce a new support condition, not merely add capacity.
Before accepting a changed penetration, slab step, wall or joint, identify the design detail governing the work and who assessed the change. A revised member and its reinforcement still depend on the soil and the structure it supports. For example, simply adding a support beneath one region may change load sharing and movement relative to adjacent regions rather than improve both.
What engineering design has to resolve
Section 4 can extend or modify the standard designs. It distinguishes stiffened rafts, other shallow systems, walls able to span without cracking and piled or piered systems, with clause 4.8 requiring design by engineering principles for the stated deep systems. Choose the design approach according to how support and structural stiffness are actually provided. Apply the relevant performance criteria, which depend in part on the supported building, details and finishes rather than on the slab taken in isolation.
Differential deflection is measured relative to a straight line between endpoints, distinguishing bending from rotation. An existing floor survey can include original levels, overall tilt, local deformation and later changes. Its overall high-to-low difference is therefore not the design deflection. Use the survey in the appraisal, not as a pass/fail check against footing design criteria.
One floor can slope between its ends while remaining close to a straight profile; another can have similar end levels but dip locally. The implications for distortion of the supported construction differ. Relate the profile to the structure and its original condition before judging the significance of the measured variation.
Verify what the design relies on during building and use
Ask where the design assumes natural ground or fill, which walls or columns locate the principal loads and what drainage and moisture conditions the system allows for. The design may need review if excavations reveal a different profile or if earthworks, finished levels or loading are revised. An engineered detail does not make changed ground or water conditions irrelevant. Show which finding would alter the design and ensure the actual response is known before the affected part is built.
Keep standard selection and engineering design identifiable on the documentation. For example, a site may otherwise suit a prescribed system but require an engineer to design a modification around a particular support. The work should show which details remain prescribed and which rely on separate analysis, so an unreviewed variation is not mistaken for part of the original provision.
For an existing building, first establish what the footing and superstructure are doing and why. A new-build detail does not diagnose ground movement or establish that introducing it will repair the existing system. Confirm the governing project basis before applying any of the AS 2870-2011 provisions discussed here.