Are Brick Colour Differences, Mortar Marks and White Deposits Defects?

Brick colour variation, mortar smears and white deposits need different checks. The Building and Plumbing Commission's Guide to Standards and Tolerances 2026 distinguishes blending in new brickwork, matching repairs as closely as practicable, normally visible stains or cleaning damage, and mortar voids. Efflorescence can point to moisture movement but cannot by itself identify a failed flashing or damp-proof course.

For new work, section 5.5 (blending and matching of masonry: new work) links significant variation in colour, texture or pattern to whether the units were mixed and distributed evenly as the manufacturer instructed. Display panels can show the expected variation and batches should be blended where practicable. Look for a departure from the intended distribution, not simply a difference in colour between two units.

Compare, for example, individual lighter units evenly distributed along a wall and a distinct rectangle of the same lighter units laid from one batch. They can involve the same brick range and still raise different questions under the blending provision. Check the intended pattern and supplier instructions instead of judging from a uniformly coloured sample brick.

Identify the finished face and whether it is a repair

Section 5.4 (masonry facing) addresses laying masonry true with the finished face outwards and removing excess mortar or stains visible under normal viewing conditions. For single-skin masonry such as a garage, the finished facing is viewed from outside, but the inside still needs to be clean and free of excess mortar. Check normal visibility in non-critical light. Use a close-up to locate the mark, not to substitute for the prescribed view.

Section 5.6 (blending and matching of masonry: repair work) allows a greater range in repair because an exact match may be unreasonable or impracticable. A joint, opening or downpipe can reduce the impact of the change where a separating feature is possible. Where reclaimed bricks are used, section 5.8 (recycled and reclaimed bricks) recognises differences in size and squareness that may make some ordinary tolerances inappropriate. These qualifications are not a reason to ignore a cracked or damaged unit, which has a separate provision. Identify whether you are comparing old and new material, a different batch in otherwise new work or physical damage to an individual brick.

Distinguish mortar appearance, surface damage and voids

Section 5.9 (mortar for masonry) assesses significant variation in mortar tone, joint finishing method or thickness from a normal viewing position. Some between-batch variation may be acceptable for site-mixed mortar. A repair needs to match the existing mortar as closely as practicable; an identical colour may not be reasonable, and differences can diminish. A raked profile beside a flush one can look different even with comparable colour. Confirm whether the concern is tone, depth or how the joint was finished.

Section 5.11 (cleaning, mortar smears and stains) treats stains, mortar smears and cleaning damage that are normally visible as outside tolerance. It also addresses significant mortar erosion from cleaning or a weak mix. Removing a smear should not be treated as a success if the process damaged the brick or eroded its joints. Compare the present surface with earlier photos where possible and differentiate surface residue from exposure of material below the original face. Timing does not by itself establish whether the cleaning method or the mortar condition caused erosion.

In section 5.10 (voids and holes in mortar) both conditions apply to a mortar void: it has to be visible from a normal viewing position and exceed 5 mm in diameter. An intentional weephole or vent that complies with the applicable building standard is a different feature. A row of small, regularly located openings above a flashing should not be filled on the premise that all holes in masonry are mortar defects. First establish whether the opening serves a drainage or ventilation function and which provision applies.

Section 5.18 (efflorescence) treats efflorescence as a possible indicator of moisture-control problems and asks for consideration of the relevant standards and possible flashing or damp-proof-course failure. White salts on the face and a mortar smear both affect appearance, but an investigation of the deposit asks where moisture arrives and dries. Compare whether the mark follows a wetting and drying route, repeats below an opening or tracks a band near the base. It may indicate a place to inspect without proving the precise concealed defect or whether water is still entering.

Appearance and performance need separate evidence. Blending records and normal-view photographs help assess appearance; tracing wetting and checking the built details help resolve a moisture concern. The advisory guide applies to domestic work within its stated scope in the issuing jurisdiction, for contracts entered into or work commencing on or after 1 August 2026. Identify whether the patch is a repair, whether cleaning damaged the mortar or whether deposits are recurring before deciding which comparison matters.